Does the euro have a future? | The Great Debate

good read...

By George SorosThe opinions expressed are his own.

The euro crisis is a direct consequence of the crash of 2008. When Lehman Brothers failed, the entire financial system started to collapse and had to be put on artificial life support. This took the form of substituting the sovereign credit of governments for the bank and other credit that had collapsed. At a memorable meeting of European finance ministers in November 2008, they guaranteed that no other financial institutions that are important to the workings of the financial system would be allowed to fail, and their example was followed by the United States.

Angela Merkel then declared that the guarantee should be exercised by each European state individually, not by the European Union or the eurozone acting as a whole. This sowed the seeds of the euro crisis because it revealed and activated a hidden weakness in the construction of the euro: the lack of a common treasury. The crisis itself erupted more than a year later, in 2010.

There is some similarity between the euro crisis and the subprime crisis that caused the crash of 2008. In each case a supposedly riskless asset—collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), based largely on mortgages, in 2008, and European government bonds now—lost some or all of their value.

To read more please see: Does the euro have a future? | The Great Debate

Griechenland Bezahl' Deine eigenen Rechnungen

This commentary is going out later than usual to coincide with the 3-year anniversary of one of the reasons I am living and working in the BVI — the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy … my beloved, albeit now infamous, former employer.  After the bankruptcy, I was fortunate enough to go on to Barclays Capital as part of their acquisition of Lehman; however, during the several weeks I had off while the two banks’ trading systems were being integrated, my friend, Steve, and I began to hatch a plan to sail the Caribbean. While we had no sailing experience, at the time, we thought getting out of the toxic atmosphere that was Manhattan was probably the healthier option (see Streak Freak below) Fast forward 3 years, and I am still in the Caribbean, Steve is married to a woman he met on Virgin Gorda and living back home in San Francisco, and the markets are once again in a similarly precarious position as to when I left.

Solvency issues that should have been contained to Greece and other periphery European countries are spreading and possibly metastasizing in some of Europe’s largest banks and insurance companies (see table below). As such we have shifted our base case scenario from the European crisis being successfully contained and minimal disruption to the European financial system to a base case where Greece defaults and possible one or multiple large European institutions need to be bailed out. 

Source: Financial Times

As a result, we have decided to ride out the current market uncertainty with a relatively conservative stance across all of our portfolios. This means we have been slightly more active over the past several months in terms of re-positioning our portfolios than we would generally like to be and have reduced high beta equities and commodities exposure, while maintaining or increasing our fixed income positions.  


Additionally we rolled our put hedges to the SPY Oct 2011 115/105 put spread and/or maintained our VXX position. (After initial success these put spreads have not produced much in terms of current returns however they have significantly reduced portfolio volatility and allowed us to sleep better knowing we are protected should the market make another big downside move.)  We expect to maintain this defensive stance until there is more clarity on how European banks will be supported in the event of a Greek default. 

We will be looking to buy again near this year’s lows (around 1100 in the S&P 500), as long as any combination of the following catalysts (with the last one being most important) are met: further stimulus from the US Fed (expected next week), the passing of Obama’s jobs bill (unlikely given the mess in Washington, but if a majority of the plan is passed then the market should rally), and Europe finally resolving their issues and insulating European banks from Greece and the other PIIGS (no longer our expected outcome).  If we get any combination of these, then we should see a huge buying opportunity possibly similar to March 2009.  Until then, we are willing to sit on the sidelines holding relatively conservative bonds and safe-haven commodities with little to no exposure to equities.  The obvious risk with this strategy is that if things are less worse than expected then the market could quickly rally higher and we will miss out on the upside.  For now, we are willing to accept this risk.

For the rest of this commentary I am going to defer to an excellent blog post from another investment manager that articulates the European dilemma much better than I can:

This week, the German Constitutional Court ruled that Germany’s role in supporting the EU’s periphery was not unlawful. The market’s knee-jerk reaction was to blast higher on the news, as the alternative would have been a total disaster. Upon closer inspection, it appears that smooth sailing into the future is far from certain. The court stressed that the decision was not a “blanket” approval for future bail-outs and demanded that the German Government “ask permission” of the Budget Committee before handing out any more cash to their southern neighbors. At the end of the day, this means that future bail-outs will be even more difficult to execute as the process is slowed further by administrative tape around afternoon siestas.

This is important. Time is quickly running out for the EU. The lack of a comprehensive solution after two years of “can kicking” means that the periphery’s disease has infected the core and the odds of a disorderly default have increased substantially. Rather than proactively addressing the challenges in the region – restructuring debt, recapitalizing banks, promoting growth, etc. – policymakers have waited for market’s to force their hand and only then, did they plug another hole in the periphery with their finger. With one year Greek debt within spitting distance of 100% yields, they are now running out of fingers. With Italian and Spanish yields back on the rise, the holes are getting too large to plug. Something’s gotta give.

To read more please go to http://www.viewfromtheblueridge.com/2011/09/09/you-lick-mine-first/

---

On a final note: to read more about Lehman Brothers (and maybe a little more on why I considered the high seas as possibly safer than an investment bank trading desk) read Streak Freak, written by the former head of my ETF Trading desk, Jared Dillian.