Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake

Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake: "In a document provided to Treasury on Friday afternoon, Standard and Poor’s (S&P) presented a judgment about the credit rating of the U.S. that was based on a $2 trillion mistake. After Treasury pointed out this error – a basic math error of significant consequence – S&P still chose to proceed with their flawed judgment by simply changing their principal rationale for their credit rating decision from an economic one to a political one.

S&P has said their decision to downgrade the U.S. was based in part on the fact that the Budget Control Act, which will reduce projected deficits by more than $2 trillion over the next 10 years, fell short of their $4 trillion expectation for deficit reduction. Clearly, in that context, S&P considers a $2 trillion change to projected deficits to be very significant. Yet, although S&P's math error understated the deficit reduction in the Budget Control Act by $2 trillion, they found this same sum insignificant in this instance."

“Just when I thought I was out … they pull me back in.”

For some reason that quote by Michael Corleone from The Godfather: Part III keeps popping into my head. For the past several months, each time we get a glimpse of a reprieve from volatile markets, new (or old) issues surface. Just when I think we have blue sky ahead, new clouds appear …

Yesterday’s market action was extremely ugly. FX intervention by the Japanese Central Bank and the Swiss National Bank enacted to weaken the Yen and Franc forced investors out of their safe-haven holdings (Yen and Francs) and simultaneously to reduce their riskier holdings—equities, commodities, etc. Furthermore, this intervention combined with weak global economic data, particularly in the US, and signs that the European Debt Crisis is spreading to larger, systemically more important countries such-as Italy to produce near panic selling.

Fortunately, last week (Thursday, July 28), we hedged some of the equities exposure for our clients invested in our 5 Model Portfolios because of the politics that were taking place in Washington. These hedges act like an insurance contract, going up in value when the markets go down—therefore protecting our clients’ portfolios if/when the markets decline. For the hedges we used one of the following strategies:

• VXX: We used the VXX ETN, which was created by my trading desk while at Barclays Capital. (In fact, I was one of the first traders to ever trade the product in 2009.) VXX tends to go up when market volatility goes up and the markets go down. 
• Vertical Put Spread: For other portfolios, we used an option strategy known as a Vertical Put Spread. For this hedge we bought the SPY Aug 20, 2011 132 / 124 Put Spread (SPY was trading around 131 at the time), which provides downside protection below 132 in the SPY, an ETF that tracks the S&P 500. 

These hedges were our response to a unique short-term opportunity where we thought we could avoid unnecessary market turbulence associated with the debt ceiling debate—effectively canceling out some of the downside market movements. Initially, we intended to only hold these hedges through the resolution of the US debt deal, however given weak global economic data and the resurgence of Europe’s debt issues we decided to maintain the hedge, which has proved a wise decision.

Please do not hesitate to contact us to learn if your portfolio is properly diversified for the current economic environment or to learn more about the hedges described above.

Bottom Line: The likelihood of some sort of QE3-like action by the US Fed has significantly increased over the last several days. Furthermore, Jean-Claude Trichet, of the European Central Bank, will likely announce additional stimulus soon as well. If/when this occurs it should provide a lift to the markets and continue downward pressure on the US dollar. In the meantime, all markets (including commodity currencies which have performed extremely well despite the world’s economic woes) will continue to be volatile; meanwhile safe-haven assets such-as Treasures, gold and possibly even the US Dollar could outperform.

Finally, at the risk of sounding like a broken record, in times of market stress like we are experiencing now it is always important to remember that these market moves are relatively minor in the context of a long-term investment strategy. As always we will diligently take the steps that we feel are appropriate to protect your portfolio—currently this is via an equity hedge and through safe-haven assets such-as US Treasuries and Gold.